The my book is reliable, fast, and less expensive than the other desktop drives we tested, plus it has enough space for your future storage. Western digital my book 8tb and my passport 4tb external hdds. Whether by chance or calculated planning, both seagate and wd recently released 4tb portable external hard disk drives. And like all desktop external hard drive, the my book require an. Seagate expansion desktop, 8 tb, externe festplatte, 3. Seagate stgy8000400 desktop 8tb external hard drive usb 3. The backup plus has 3 years warranty period, where the expansion offers 2 years warranty period. Seagate expansion on mac, want it but can i use on my mac. Which is the best external hard drive, seagate or wd.
Wd my book is a very popular and one of the more expensive options. I see a lot more failed seagate drives than western digital drives. When you need lots of onthego space for an evergrowing collection of files, you can trust our highperformance portable hard drives to get the job done. Comparison of seagate backup plus 1 tb slim vs western digital my passport ultra external hard drives.
Wd my passport is ranked 4th while seagate expansion 1tb portable external hard drive is ranked 6th. My first question is, is there any reason beyond greedy business practices that explain why the ex2 ultra is. Wd my book vs wd elements external drives for pc wd. The western digital 2tb desktop hard drive is an elegant, highcapacity storage solution for all the chapters of your digital life. Seagate drives have by far the highest rate of failure of any hard drive manufacturer. Western digital my book 4 tb desktop hard drive black the drive is incredibly easy to remove and has been installed in my synology nas, greatly increasing its capacity. The my book doesnt have extra usb ports to work as a usb hub, a cool feature first introduced by the seagate backup plus hub. The seagate 8tb backup plus hub is a very appealing option for anyone that needs a large capacity device to backup their computer, and other devices. Western digital 6000gb wd my book wdbbgb0060hbkeesn 3.
The seagate backup plus is more compact and light weight than seagate expansion. It supports a 500 gb to 4 tb storage capacity, which in turn allows you to keep your mandatory data applications and digital library safe. I always use western digital drives for replacement parts. It is an excellent option for expanding the capacity of your computer and is amazingly easy and intuitive to use. Hello friends, im going to buy an external 4tb hdd. I need to buy a new external hard drive and seem to be seagate against wd ive seen that seagate is 10krpm yet has more failure rates but is. External hard drives free delivery possible on eligible purchases. Pretty good price for such a large capacity dualdrive which i use in raid 1 mode so all my data is backed up within the drive. Seagate expansion vs seagate backup plus hub vs wd elements vs wd my book. Seagate expansion is a very popular and one of the most affordable options. Nov 19, 2019 what is the difference between wd my book vs wd elements.
Western digitals 4 tb my book is the best desktop hard drive for most people because its reliable and it offers the best balance of speed and price. Seagate backup plus desktop is a very popular option in the middle of the external hard drives price range. Slant wd my passport vs seagate backup plus slim detailed. Password protection indicates whether the hard drive has password protection as a security measure against unauthorised entry. Seagate expansion and backup plus pull apart whats the. You can even double them up and let them sit neatly together like volumes on your shelf. Apr 14, 2020 seagate stgy8000400 desktop 8tb external hard drive usb 3. Comparison of seagate backup plus vs seagate expansion. Wd 8tb usb my book vs seagate 8tb backup plus hub pc. Can seagate ironwolf 3tb drives work in my cloud ex2 ultra. Test wd my book desktop 8 tb externe desktop festplatte test. The another important difference between these two hard disks is about warranty period. Seagate expansion 1tb portable external hard drive vs wd. Apr 21, 2020 as for seagate, they can provide 10tb of storage from a singledrive backup plus hub or expansion desktop.
When comparing seagate expansion 1tb portable external hard drive vs wd my passport, the slant community recommends wd my passport for most people. The 4tb seagate backup plus portable hard drive is so much more than what it seems and it already seems like a whole heck of a lot. Sep 04, 2017 i bought a driveless my cloud ex2 ultra and 2 3tb seagate ironwolf drives. Feb 21, 2017 the seagate has a 2 year and the wd 3 year. Unless you live in the usa, in which case you may wish to weigh up the 1 year vs 3 year warranty. I prefer the design and bit lower price of the seagate, but actual performance and long term reliability is more important for me. Seagate expansion or wd mybook for external hard drive.
The weight of seagate backup plus is 224g, where seagate expansion is 270g. The my book is reliable, fast, and less expensive than the other desktop drives we tested, plus it has enough space for your future storage needs and a long, threeyear warranty. Which external hard drive is better, seagate or wd. Both drives are suitable for backup if you just need basic storage for backup purposes the wd elements is the cheaper option. Seagate backup plus 1 tb slim vs western digital my. Seagate backup plus is an easy way to protect and share your digital life. Seagate vs western digital what are the differences on. Ps4 8tb external hard drive guide ps4 storage expert. You can have it and use your seagate expansion on your macbook pro, macbook air or imac.
My book duo desktop raid storage wd discovery software for wd backup, wd security and wd drive utilities usbc to usbc cable usbc to usba cable ac adapter disk replacement tool quick install guide. The my book unit also comes with a kensington lock slot. I bought a driveless my cloud ex2 ultra and 2 3tb seagate ironwolf drives. Both are well matched in some aspects yet deviating in others. Instantly add space for more files, consolidate all of your files to a single location, or free up space on your computers internal drive to help improve performance. Wd 8tb usb my book vs seagate 8tb backup plus hub pc storage.
Pretty good price for such a large capacity dualdrive which i use in raid 1. We pit the two against each other to find out which is better. Compare seagate 4tb backup plus portable hard drive vs wd 4tb my book desktop usb 3. Compare seagate 4tb backup plus portable hard drive vs wd 4tb. As for seagate, they can provide 10tb of storage from a singledrive backup plus hub or expansion desktop. Both desktop drives have mass storage for photos, videos, music and document backups.
Seagate expansion, toshiba canvio, western digital my book avtv. Buy seagate expansion portable 1tb external hard drive hdd usb 3. Ready to go with up to 5tb of storage space for your most important files, the sleek and protective metal finish is available in classic black, silver, red or blue. External hard disk comparison seagate vs toshiba vs wd. If you like the western digital my book but want to save even more money, the seagate expansion desktop is for you. I work with wd, hitachi, seagate, samsung, and toshiba hard drives. The seagate backup plus and the seagate expansion are exactly the same hard drive put into a different case.
To buy the products shown in the video at best price, here is the link. Which external hard drive is better, seagate or wd elements. Sep 28, 2019 the answer to both questions is a big yes. Seagate expansion desktop drive, addon storage for your pc the seagate expansion desktop drive provides extra storage for your evergrowing collection of files. I would like to backup old computer and transfer files to new computer. My current ehd is a maxtor onetouch iii, thats about two. Also, because of its backup plus 640 mbps external data transfer rate, it enables you to read and write your never to be missed data. It has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as lacie d2 quadra v3 or wd my book. Below we have provided a comparison between seagate backup plus and seagate expansion on similarities and dissimilarities basis mentioning both their features and performance. Seagate expansion 1tb portable external hard drive vs wd my.
The western digital my book new 4tb has a password protection, but the seagate expansion external hard drive 4 tb does not. What is the difference between wd my book vs wd elements. Test wd my book desktop 8 tb externe desktop festplatte test externe. Its in the top 3 bestselling external hard drives and has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as adata hd710 or wd my passport ultra 1tb. It can indeed be used for all models of ps4 game console if you have an incredibly large collection of games to install, although for consoles there are drives that can save you an additional few seconds in load times if that matters. It is an excellent option for expanding the capacity of your computer and. However, if you want to do 4k or even 8k video editing, or backup other massive media collection, western digital is your best choice.
Seagate expansion 8tb desktop external hdd is a fantastic external solution for large backups and media collections alike. The real trick is determining which from each company is good vs lemon. The seagate backup plus portable is like taking a western digital my book, removing some of the performance and shrinking it down to a 2. One of the most important things to keep in mind when picking a hard drive, or any kind of storage hardware for that matter is reliability. Western digital wins out when it comes to larger capacities, offering its my book duo with 20tb of storage in either a raid 0 or raid 1 configuration, along with plenty of connectivity.
Hard drives from large companies like wd and seagate are going to be fine. Western digital my book 8tb and my passport 4tb external hdds the new chassis design is definitely more stylish compared to the. Personally id go wd since i do remember the seagate mess, but thats an emotional thing rather than any logic. In the end, you would not go wrong with your decision. After 20 hours of new research and testing, we found that the best external desktop hard drive for most people is western digitals 4 tb my book. May 24, 2017 the mammoth 8tb capacity on the wd 8tb my book is the largest i have seen to date of this size in terms of dimension, as it measures only 170mm by 140mm. The western digital wd my passport wireless 2tb, which sells for. And youll find out all the things to know and keep in mind. Compare the main features, specifications, prices and select the best model. Oct 11, 2016 the my book doesnt have extra usb ports to work as a usb hub, a cool feature first introduced by the seagate backup plus hub. They are built to be the cheapest, and their low quality build shows in their desinlgns. Western digital my book 8tb and my passport 4tb external hdds the new chassis design is definitely more stylish compared to. The most important reason people chose seagate backup plus slim is. While wds my passport pro offers thunderbolt connectivity, seagate s backup plus fast is adamant that usb 3.
Wd my book essentials 3tb posted in external hardware. My first question is, is there any reason beyond greedy business practices that explain why the ex2 ultra is incompatible with nonwd drives. Wd my book vs wd elements external drives for pc wd community. Seagate expansion desktop 8tb external hard drive hdd usb 3. Hi folks, im looking to buy an external hard drive to serve as backup media for my laptop. Its in the top 3 bestselling external hard drives and has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as transcend 25m3 or avolusion portable hd250u3.
Based on 7,623 user benchmarks for the wd elements and the my book 1140, we rank them both on effective speed and value for money against the best 639 usbs. All my storage drives are wd, mostly because of seagates history. With a reliable brand thats been around forever, plus a newlyintroduced storage system with higherthanever capacities, this is a portable drive you truly wont want to miss. Upon setup have learned that this device only accepts wd drives, something that of course, wasnt mentioned anywhere in the material i read when researching nas solutions. Im a very much confused between wd my book 4tb external hard drive. Western digital my book 4 tb vs seagate backup plus 4 tb. Smaller, sleeker and more elegant than previous my book external hard drives, the my book essential hard drive takes up minimal space on your desk. Its in the top 3 bestselling external hard drives and has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as adata hd710 or wd my passport ultra 1tb seagate backup plus desktop was released in 2015. While wds my passport pro offers thunderbolt connectivity, seagates backup plus fast is adamant that usb 3. Compare seagate 4tb backup plus portable hard drive vs wd. The desktop seagate 8tb external drive is our definite favorite among all options we could test this year. Western digital my book 8tb and my passport 4tb external. Wd my books have password protection and hardware encryption. I do have a 3tb seagate though since the external update and its worked as expected.
Seagate vs western digital what are the differences on storage. The seagate desktop hdd 4 tb st4000dm000 spins at 5,900 rpm, has 64 mib of cache and uses a sata600 interface. By contrast, the best seagate can muster is 10tb of storage from the singledrive backup plus hub or expansion desktop. Overall, as far as performance is concerned, the seagate expansion is about as good as it. The western digital my book duo 20tb, which is priced at. It was about as fast as the competition in all of our tests, its the least expensive drive we tested at this writing, and it has a longer warranty three years. This is quick unboxing of a seagate expansion usb 3.